I recently ordered a photo book of pictures from our honeymoon, and was so excited to use Artifact Uprising. I had only read great reviews. Their site was easy to use (and gorgeous, a huge one-up for me) and my photo book arrived just a week after I ordered. I highly recommend! Maybe an album of you and your girlfriends throughout college? Or you could gift one to your parents (I love the idea of an "ugly book" using only awful candid family shots)!
All images via That's Pretty Ace